Aspo - A cooling-off period for ESL
Issues with larger and smaller vessels; Handysize performs
Aspo cut guidance shortly after Q1 report as Q2 seems weaker than earlier expected and especially as ESL’s FY ’23 outlook has turned even softer after a record-year. The market for Supramaxes has weakened for a while, but their current drag on profitability seems larger than estimated before. Coasters’ profitability suffers from higher rental costs as well as capacity issues, in addition to which Q2 and Q3 dockings will have further impact, however Handysize vessels still seem to perform stable this year. The hybrid Coasters should add some earnings already next year; the outlook for Supramaxes has likely improved by FY ’24, however ESL is set to divest its two vessels soon and use the proceeds to help fund expansion within the Handysize segment as Northern Sweden by itself should see more than SEK 1,000bn in industrial investments over the next 20 years.
We estimate ESL’s EBIT to decline by a third this year
We previously estimated ESL’s FY ’22 EBIT of EUR 37m to decline to EUR 30m this year; our new EUR 25m estimate stands quite well in line with the only “normal” level of FY ‘21 for ESL’s current fleet structure as the past years’ investments first had to weather demand challenges (as well as technical issues) before and early in the pandemic, whereas last year’s result proved simply too high to sustain with current capacity levels. In our view ESL’s profitability (and capacity excluding the Supramaxes) should improve at least modestly next year so long as demand stays roughly stable around current levels. We now estimate ESL FY ’24 EBIT at EUR 30.0m (prev. EUR 31.5m).
Not too expensive, but ESL’s softness limits near potential
We leave our Leipurin estimates unchanged, whereas we make small downward revisions to our Telko estimates. Aspo’s organic profitability development should stabilize going towards next year, assuming no larger demand headwinds prevail. EUR 40m hence appears a realistic EBIT level again next year; the corresponding 8.5x EV/EBIT isn’t that high, but this year’s softness raises the multiple to 11x and limits upside potential. Our new TP is EUR 8.0 (9.5); our rating is now HOLD (BUY).